Typical insulated-door U-factor (lower is better) |
Approximately 0.15–0.35 Btu/h·ft²·°F for insulated, glazed residential units. |
Approximately 0.15–0.35 Btu/h·ft²·°F for insulated units; the core and glass configuration are decisive. |
Approximately 0.25–0.50 Btu/h·ft²·°F; solid wood and larger glass areas generally perform less efficiently. |
Approximately 0.15–0.35 Btu/h·ft²·°F for insulated composite systems; product construction varies widely. |
Approximate center-of-slab R-value (higher is better) |
Typically R-4 to R-7 for insulated residential slabs. |
Typically R-4 to R-7 when foam insulated; uninsulated steel has much lower thermal resistance. |
Typically R-2 to R-3 for a solid wood slab, depending on species and thickness. |
Typically R-4 to R-7 when manufactured with an insulated core. |
| Air leakage |
Material does not determine leakage. A properly weatherstripped and installed unit can meet an air-leakage limit of ≤0.3 cfm/ft² at 1.57 psf, a common ENERGY STAR benchmark. |
Can meet the same benchmark when the slab, frame, weatherstripping, and threshold are correctly engineered and installed. |
Can meet the same benchmark, but seasonal movement makes accurate sealing and adjustment especially important. |
Can meet the same benchmark when the complete door system has been tested as an assembly. |
| Weather and moisture resistance |
Very good. Does not rust and is less prone to swelling than wood; edge and finish protection still matter. |
Good with maintenance. Steel can rust if the protective coating is damaged or water reaches unprotected edges. |
Moderate. Requires effective overhangs, sealed edges, proper drainage, and regular finish maintenance. |
Very good. Generally resists moisture and movement well, but seals, joints, and the frame remain critical. |
| Resistance to dents and impact |
Good resistance to everyday impacts; deep damage may be difficult to repair invisibly. |
Very good. Strong skin and core options resist many common impacts, although dents can be difficult to refinish. |
Good repairability for many surface defects; softer species can dent or scratch more easily. |
Good, depending on the outer skin; repairability differs by composite formulation. |
| Resistance to warping and seasonal movement |
Very good. Low moisture movement compared with solid wood. |
Very good. Generally dimensionally stable; thermal expansion and frame installation still need consideration. |
Lowest of the four. Humidity, temperature, water exposure, and grain orientation can cause movement. |
Very good. Usually stable, though performance depends on the core, skins, and frame design. |
| Corrosion and rot risk |
Does not rot or corrode; hardware and fasteners can still corrode in coastal environments. |
Corrosion risk if coating is breached. Use appropriate primers, coatings, and corrosion-resistant hardware. |
Rot risk if repeatedly exposed to moisture. Seal all six sides and maintain exposed finishes. |
Low material rot and corrosion risk; metal hardware and reinforcement may still require protection. |
| Typical finish-maintenance cycle |
Inspect annually; repaint or refinish commonly every 5–10 years, depending on exposure and finish. |
Inspect annually; repaint commonly every 5–10 years or sooner if the coating is damaged or chalking. |
Inspect at least annually. Recoat commonly every 2–5 years, depending on exposure, finish, and overhang. |
Inspect annually; repainting or refinishing commonly every 5–10 years, depending on the surface system. |
| Thermal-bridge risk |
Low to moderate; glazing, frame material, and threshold can create thermal bridges. |
Moderate to high without a thermal break. Look for insulated cores, thermal breaks, and insulated frames. |
Low through the slab; glass, hardware, frame, and perimeter gaps can still reduce overall performance. |
Low to moderate; verify the tested whole-door U-factor rather than judging the skin alone. |
| Security considerations |
Strong security is achievable; resistance depends more on the frame, lockset, hinges, strike reinforcement, and glazing than on the skin alone. |
Often offers a rigid, impact-resistant skin, but a thin skin or weak frame can still be vulnerable. |
Can provide strong security with a substantial slab and reinforced frame; material strength alone is not a security rating. |
Can provide strong security when paired with a reinforced core, quality frame, and tested hardware system. |
| Sound-control potential |
Good with a dense insulated core, compression seals, and limited glazing; request a tested STC rating where available. |
Good with an insulated, dense core and continuous seals; hollow or poorly sealed units perform worse. |
Good because of mass, particularly with a solid slab; perimeter seals and glazing remain significant. |
Good to very good when the slab is dense and the complete assembly is well sealed. |
| Environmental considerations |
Long service life is possible; manufacturing and end-of-life recycling options vary by product composition. |
Steel contains commonly recycled material and is recyclable in many waste streams, subject to local facilities and coatings. |
Renewable or reclaimed wood can reduce material impacts; responsible sourcing and durable finishing are important. |
Material recipes vary; many composite skins and cores are difficult to separate and recycle. |
| Best fit for |
Homeowners prioritizing low maintenance, moisture resistance, and balanced energy performance. |
Projects prioritizing impact resistance, security feel, and value, with willingness to maintain the coating. |
Traditional appearance, repairability, customization, and natural material character. |
Low movement, strong weather resistance, and a wood-like appearance with reduced routine maintenance. |
| What to verify before buying |
Whole-door U-factor, air-leakage test result, frame type, finish warranty, sill drainage, and glazing specification. |
Insulation level, thermal break, corrosion protection, skin thickness, whole-door U-factor, and coating warranty. |
Moisture-management design, species, slab thickness, edge sealing, finish system, overhang, and maintenance requirements. |
Exact material formulation, core type, tested U-factor, water-management details, repair method, and warranty exclusions. |